Understanding consumer behaviour is crucial for effective brand strategy in modern marketing. However, a common misconception persists the belief that brands can distinctly segment their audience to achieve better results. This notion has been debunked by the Law of Brand User Profiles, which suggests that the customer bases of competing brands are remarkably similar. This article explores the Law of Brand User Profiles and its implications for B2C and B2B marketing, particularly in the Japanese market, to help brands leverage this understanding for strategic growth.
Table of Contents
Explanation of the Law of Brand User Profiles
The Law of Brand User Profiles, formulated by the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, posits that the customer profiles of rival brands seldom differ. This principle is rooted in extensive research across various industries, showing that despite targeted marketing efforts, customers' demographic and behavioural characteristics remain consistent across competing brands. Essentially, brands do not get to choose their customer composition; rather, the size of their customer base is what varies. As Byron Sharp puts it, “The evidence shows that rival brands can, and do, sell to all types of customers. Your competitors’ customers can become yours. They resemble your existing customers. No category buyer is off limits, so include as many as possible in your marketing activities.”
Importance of Recognising Similarities in Consumer Profiles in Japan
Recognising similarities in consumer profiles in Japan is vital for several reasons. It challenges the effectiveness of hyper-targeting, a strategy often employed in B2B and B2C marketing that focuses on narrow customer segments. By understanding that potential buyers for any brand are broadly similar, marketers can shift their focus from segment-specific targeting to broader, more inclusive strategies that reach a wider audience, optimizing both reach and cost-effectiveness.
Detailed Explanation of the Concept
The Law of Brand User Profiles is grounded in empirical research that spans decades. Studies have consistently shown that brands within the same category compete for the same pool of customers. For instance, in the credit card market, the age and gender distribution of customers remains consistent across different brands, regardless of their market share (see the data for yourself in the chart below). This phenomenon is not limited to consumer goods but extends to B2B markets, including sectors like infrastructure-as-a-service (IaaS) and customer relationship management (CRM).
Credit Card Users by Brand | Market Share (%) | Male (%) | Female (%) | Age 15-19 (%) | Age 20-24 (%) | Age 25-34 (%) | Age 35-44 (%) | Age 45-54 (%) | Age 55-64 (%) | Age 65+ (%) |
Barclaycard Visa | 31 | 51 | 49 | 1 | 4 | 17 | 23 | 21 | 18 | 14 |
TSB Trust Card | 14 | 51 | 49 | 1 | 3 | 18 | 20 | 21 | 19 | 18 |
Access Natwest | 11 | 54 | 47 | 1 | 2 | 16 | 24 | 22 | 20 | 14 |
Access Midlands | 10 | 52 | 48 | 1 | 3 | 18 | 24 | 21 | 20 | 13 |
Barclays MasterCard | 9 | 60 | 40 | 1 | 3 | 15 | 21 | 23 | 20 | 17 |
Access Lloyds | 8 | 54 | 46 | 2 | 2 | 18 | 22 | 22 | 20 | 13 |
B. of Scotland Visa | 4 | 56 | 44 | 1 | 2 | 17 | 21 | 26 | 19 | 14 |
Co-op Bank Visa | 4 | 53 | 48 | 1 | 2 | 15 | 24 | 24 | 19 | 15 |
Midland Visa | 4 | 56 | 45 | 1 | 6 | 18 | 20 | 21 | 18 | 16 |
TSB MasterCard | 4 | 56 | 44 | 1 | 2 | 16 | 22 | 22 | 20 | 20 |
Average Brand | 10 | 54 | 46 | 1 | 3 | 17 | 22 | 22 | 19 | 15 |
Scroll for details: Source: TCI
Implications for Brand Strategy
The implications of this law are profound. It suggests that brands should focus on increasing their market penetration rather than attempting to create highly segmented marketing campaigns. By adopting a broad targeting strategy, brands can effectively reach more potential buyers, maximizing their market share and growth potential. Hyper-targeting might be the single most destructive idea in B2B marketing. Why? While it may seem logical, beneath the surface, you’ll find that the assumptions don’t line up with real-world evidence on how B2B brands grow.
Analysis of User Base Similarities in Japan
Insights into Common User Base Characteristics
In Japan, the law of brand user profiles is true across various industries. Japanese consumers exhibit consistent demographic and behavioural traits, making hyper-targeting less effective. For example, the consumer electronics market in Japan shows little variation in customer profiles between competing brands like Sony and Panasonic. Both brands attract a similar mix of age groups and income levels, highlighting the universal appeal of their products.
Cultural and Market-Specific Factors
Japan’s unique cultural and market-specific factors also play a role in reinforcing the Law of Brand User Profiles. The homogeneity of Japanese society and the country’s collectivist culture means consumer behaviour is less fragmented than more diverse markets. This uniformity simplifies the application of broad marketing strategies, as brands can confidently target a wide audience without losing relevance.
Strategies to Grow User Bases
Techniques for Expanding User Bases
To capitalize on the Law of Brand User Profiles, brands should adopt strategies focusing on expanding their overall user base rather than narrowing their target audience. Some effective techniques include:
Broad Reach Advertising: Invest in advertising channels that reach a large audience, such as television and outdoor media, to ensure maximum exposure.
Consistent Brand Messaging: Maintain a consistent brand message across all platforms to build brand recognition and trust among a wide audience.
Inclusive Product Development: Design products and services that cater to a broad range of consumers, enhancing the brand’s appeal to different demographic segments.
Focus on Increasing Brand Size
Increasing the size of the customer base should be a primary goal for brands. This involves not only attracting new customers but also retaining existing ones. Strategies to achieve this include:
Loyalty Programs: Implement loyalty programs that reward repeat purchases and foster long-term customer relationships.
Promotional Campaigns: Run promotional campaigns that offer incentives for new customers to try the brand, such as discounts or free trials.
Customer Engagement: Engage with customers through multiple touchpoints, including social media, email marketing, and customer service, to build a strong connection with the brand.
Examples of Japanese Brands Successfully Growing Their User Base
Several Japanese brands have successfully applied the principles of the Law of Brand User Profiles to grow their user base. Let’s look at a few examples:
Uniqlo: The clothing retailer has grown remarkably by appealing to a broad audience with its affordable, high-quality apparel. Uniqlo’s marketing campaigns focus on the universal appeal of its products rather than targeting specific consumer segments.
Toyota: As one of Japan’s leading automobile manufacturers, Toyota has maintained a consistent brand message focused on reliability and innovation. This broad appeal has helped Toyota attract a diverse domestic and international customer base.
SoftBank: In the telecommunications sector, SoftBank has grown its market share by offering inclusive service packages that cater to a wide range of consumers, from individual users to large corporations.
The success of these brands can be attributed to their understanding of the Law of Brand User Profiles and their strategic application of broad targeting. These brands have attracted and retained a large, diverse customer base by focusing on inclusive marketing and product development.
Deeper Dive: Practical Applications in Japan
Practical Applications for Entering the Japanese Market
For foreign brands looking to enter the Japanese market, understanding and applying the Law of Brand User Profiles can significantly enhance their chances of success. Here are some practical steps:
Market Research: Conduct thorough market research to understand the common characteristics of your potential customer base in Japan. Utilize existing data from similar brands to identify trends and preferences.
Adaptation to Local Preferences: While the core principle of broad targeting remains, it’s crucial to adapt your products and marketing messages to align with Japanese cultural preferences. For example, emphasize quality and reliability, which are highly valued by Japanese consumers.
Building Trust: Japanese consumers place a high value on trust and reliability. Establishing a strong, trustworthy brand image through consistent quality and excellent customer service is essential.
Leveraging Local Media: Use local media channels that have a broad reach. Television, newspapers, and online platforms like LINE can help you reach a wide audience effectively.
Partnerships with Local Brands: Collaborate with established local brands to gain credibility and reach a wider audience. This can be particularly effective in the early stages of market entry.
Example: IKEA in Japan
IKEA’s Strategy: IKEA, the Swedish furniture giant, provides an excellent example of how a foreign brand can successfully enter and grow in the Japanese market by applying the Law of Brand User Profiles. IKEA’s strategy in Japan involved:
Localization of Products: Adapting its product range to fit the smaller living spaces common in Japanese homes.
Broad Marketing Campaigns: Launching extensive marketing campaigns that targeted a wide audience, emphasizing IKEA’s combination of affordability and quality.
Building a Strong Brand Presence: Establishing large, easily accessible stores in key locations to maximize visibility and customer footfall.
Customer Experience Focus: Creating a unique shopping experience that combines product display with in-store dining options, enhancing customer engagement and satisfaction.
Example: Starbucks in Japan
Starbucks’ Strategy: The global coffeehouse chain has also effectively applied the Law of Brand User Profiles. Starbucks’ approach included:
Cultural Adaptation: Introducing menu items that cater to local tastes, such as matcha (green tea) flavoured beverages and seasonal sakura (cherry blossom) drinks.
Community Engagement: Creating store designs that reflect local culture and aesthetics, fostering a sense of community and belonging among customers.
Broad Marketing Efforts: Utilizing social media platforms and in-store promotions to reach a wide audience, enhancing brand visibility and customer engagement.
Practical Tips for Applying the Law of Brand User Profiles in Japan
Comprehensive Market Research
Consumer Insights: Gather detailed data on consumer preferences, behaviours, and demographics to identify common characteristics.
Competitive Analysis: Study the customer profiles of competing brands to understand the market landscape and identify opportunities for differentiation.
Inclusive Product Development
Versatile Products: Develop products that cater to a wide range of consumers, ensuring broad appeal and usability.
Quality Assurance: Maintain high standards of quality and reliability to build trust and loyalty among Japanese consumers.
Broad Marketing Strategies
Mass Media Advertising: Utilize television, radio, and print media to reach a large audience, ensuring maximum exposure.
Digital Marketing: Leverage online platforms, social media, and influencer partnerships to engage with a diverse customer base.
Consistent Messaging: Ensure your brand message is consistent across all channels, reinforcing your brand’s core values and appeal.
Building Strong Customer Relationships
Customer Service: Provide exceptional customer service to build trust and loyalty, addressing customer concerns promptly and effectively.
Community Engagement: Participate in local events and community activities to foster a sense of belonging and connection with your brand.
The Law of Brand User Profiles provides valuable insights for brands looking to grow their B2C and B2B market share. By recognizing the similarities in B2C consumer and B2B client profiles across competing brands, marketers can shift their focus from hyper-targeting to broad targeting strategies. This approach is particularly effective in the Japanese market, where cultural and societal factors reinforce the uniformity of consumer behaviour. Brands that embrace this understanding and implement inclusive marketing strategies are well-positioned for sustainable growth.
FAQ Section
What is the Law of Brand User Profiles?
The Law of Brand User Profiles posits that the customer profiles of competing brands are remarkably similar. This principle, based on extensive research by the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, indicates that despite targeted marketing efforts, customers' demographic and behavioural characteristics do not significantly differ across rival brands.
Why is recognising user base similarities important in marketing?
Recognising user base similarities is crucial as it challenges the effectiveness of hyper-targeting, which focuses on narrow customer segments. Understanding that potential buyers are broadly similar allows marketers to adopt inclusive strategies, enhancing reach and cost-effectiveness by targeting a wider audience rather than specific segments.
How does the Law of Brand User Profiles apply in Japan?
In Japan, the law of brand user profiles is true across various industries. Due to the homogeneity of Japanese society and its collectivist culture, consumer behaviour exhibits consistent demographic and behavioural traits. This uniformity makes broad marketing strategies more effective compared to hyper-targeting.
What strategies can brands use to grow their user base?
Brands can grow their user base by adopting broad targeting strategies. Effective techniques include investing in broad-reach advertising, maintaining consistent brand messaging, developing inclusive products, implementing loyalty programs, running promotional campaigns, and engaging with customers through multiple touchpoints.
How have Japanese brands successfully applied the Law of Brand User Profiles?
Japanese brands like Uniqlo, Toyota, and SoftBank have successfully applied the Law of Brand User Profiles by focusing on broad targeting and inclusive marketing strategies. These brands have grown their user base by appealing to a wide audience through consistent branding, high-quality products, and broad-reach advertising.
Ready to learn how to launch, integrate and scale your business in Japan?
Download our intro deck and contact ULPA today to understand how we will help your company learn the rules of business in Japan, and then redefine those rules.
Let The Adventure Begin.
Comments